The chain of custody is essential to guarantee that products bearing a certification label truly come from responsibly managed sources. But when a company wants to get certified, the question often arises: what is the difference between FSC and PEFC and, especially, between their chain of custody requirements?
Even though the standards are similar in many ways – both recognize traceability, transparency and compliance with legal requirements –, there are significant differences in approach, structure and implementation.
1. Chain of Custody Objective
Both FSC and PEFC aim to maintain traceability of certified materials throughout all stages of production, processing and distribution. Each link in the chain (harvesting, transport, processing, packaging, sales) must demonstrate that it correctly separates and labels certified products.
2. Accepted Chain of Custody Models
Both systems recognize three traceability models: Physical separation (certified materials are kept separate), Mass balance (physical mixing with accounting balance) and Percentage (percentage of certified materials communicated transparently).
FSC
FSC has more detailed requirements for internal balance control and requires a stricter calculation methodology.
PEFC
PEFC gives organizations more freedom to define their method, as long as traceability can be demonstrated.
3. "Controlled" Materials
FSC has a special category for uncertified materials – called "Controlled Wood" – and imposes strict rules for risk assessment.
FSC
Separate standard for controlling these materials with strict assessment of origin, legality and impact.
PEFC
PEFC only requires that uncertified materials be legal and not come from controversial sources.
4. Association Policy
FSC applies a detailed association policy, which extends ethical responsibility to the entire company or group it belongs to.
FSC
If a company is involved in serious violations, it may lose the right to participate in the system – even if the deviations are not related to the certified activity.
PEFC
PEFC does not apply this policy directly, being more permissive regarding company reputation.
5. Audit and Control Frequency
Both systems require annual audits, but there are differences in approach.
FSC
FSC additionally requires unannounced audits for a certain percentage of certificates annually.
PEFC
Accreditation standards differ slightly, influencing the working style of certification bodies.
6. Product Label Usage
Both FSC and PEFC allow the use of the label on the product and/or on commercial documents.
FSC
FSC is stricter regarding the placement, colors and size of the logo.
PEFC
PEFC requires prior approval for promotional materials.
7. Group Certification Rules
Group certification is possible in both systems, but with notable differences.
FSC
FSC has more detailed requirements for member audits, including mandatory annual physical checks.
PEFC
PEFC leaves the verification method more at the discretion of the central office, offering flexibility.
8. Standards Structure and Transparency
In general, FSC is more detailed, with more requirements and indicators. PEFC is more concise and flexible, but requires more interpretation.
FSC
FSC publishes a summary for each certification audit.
PEFC
PEFC does not require publication of results, only their internal archiving.
Which is Better?
There is no universal answer. It depends on your company profile, customer requirements, maturity of internal systems, organizational culture and appetite for documentation.
- Some companies choose to be certified in both systems to meet the needs of all customers
- Others choose the system that gives them access to the desired market, with reasonable administrative requirements
- We recommend analyzing the requirements of your main customers before deciding
Conclusion
The chain of custody is a technical but crucial component in ensuring certification credibility. Both FSC and PEFC have strengths and different approaches. The important thing is to understand these differences and choose knowingly – not just based on perception, but based on what fits your company and your commercial and operational objectives.
Related Articles
We Help You Choose the Right Certification
Contact us for a free consultation and we will analyze together which system suits your business
Or call directly:
+40 701 543 735